7*; 1917 Movie (2019)

World War I battlefield
Based on stories handed down

This modern ‘you are there’ film brings the viewer into the action, as did A Private War. It hardly seems possible to film action scenes in the hopeless trenches of WWI, but that is accomplished well here.

“1917” sticks to the mission portrayed for two soldiers, a match for “Saving Private Ryan” in terms of staying on track. Both are graphic. While the WWII tale is more epic in scale with its depiction of war, this WWI film is more inside the fate-accepting mind of the lonely soldier.

It is a battlefield setting but a personal tale of perseverance and commitment. It is a refreshing individual soldier’s story rather than that of generals and leaders. It is more “To Hell and Back” than “Patton,” more about the meek than the commanding, more Audie Murphy than George C. Scott.

Returning to the first comparison above, the strongest feature of 1917 is that it maintains the story arc better than Private War despite not reaching the same depth of character portrayal. Private War seemed superior in regard to putting the viewer into a setting with all the senses, to virtually feel, hear, smell, and taste the action.

With 1917, I was there as a viewer, making it best on a big broad theater screen. Private War was excellent on just an airliner seat-back display. While 1917 is an appealing soldier’s story, I expect the journalistic angle and modernity of the other will appeal to more people.

However, IMDB ratings for the two refute me … which is why certain friends know to make their own choices for cinema, not follow mine.

If tolerable of scenes showing wartime horror, I endorse seeing the “1917” movie to be taken into an era too far forgotten a century later.

*(star) rating in the title is mine; e.g. 7*=Seven Stars (maximum 10)

4 thoughts on “7*; 1917 Movie (2019)”

  1. Hello Doug and I am very glad to read a post from you after such a long time. You have made a great critique of what appears to be a very interesting movie, which I’ve not yet seen. I find that movies that focus on the individual, non-important or the simple, day to day person are much more enjoyable and believable than those that seek to glorify the leader or the commander. I had not thought about seeing “1917” but I’ve now decided it is worth seeing in the big screen. Thanks for such keen insights and great writing! All the best to you, Happy New Year and greetings from Spain,

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are welcome and encouraged!!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.